A correction has been published on this article (The Lancet 2025; 405(10477): 468). It corrects the appendix, for labelling inconsistencies. The sentences cited here are in the Summary, the Results and the Discussion.
p. 1, Summary, "Findings"; restated p. 2, "Added value of this study"
| Document | Traumatic injury mortality in the Gaza Strip from Oct 7, 2023, to June 30, 2024: a capture–recapture analysis 2 |
| Published | 2025-01-09 |
| Address | https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(24)02678-3 |
| Archived copy | 2025-01-24 |
| Access | primary |
| Period covered | 2023-10-07 → 2024-06-30 |
| Corroboration | corroborated |
The document was re-opened on 2026-09-28 and the quoted sentence appears in it word for word, at the address below.
https://researchonline.lshtm.ac.uk/id/eprint/4674812/2/Jamaluddine-etal-2025-Traumatic-inj
How this is checked, and how to check it yourself
Three-list capture–recapture analysis combining Palestinian Ministry of Health hospital morgue lists, a Ministry of Health online survey, and obituaries published on public social media pages (p. 2–3). The method infers deaths absent from every list; it is not a count of identified individuals.
A reserve stated by the authors themselves, p. 7: “Our findings underestimate the full impact of the military operation in Gaza, as they do not account for non-trauma-related deaths resulting from health service disruption, food insecurity, and inadequate water and sanitation.” The estimate therefore covers traumatic injury only. A further reserve, p. 3: 930 people reported missing were excluded from the main analysis, with a sensitivity analysis including them as assumed decedents.
Published responses in The Lancet. In the same issue, a commentary by Smith, Shellah and Samudzi, “On the quantification of military violence in Gaza” (2025; 405(10477): 440–442), which comments on this article and on one other; its text has not been read. In the issue of 7 June 2025, a Correspondence by Zivot, Paltiel, Sim and Wald, “Gaza deaths and lawful warfare” (vol. 405, pp. 2047–2048), and the authors’ reply (p. 2048). The Correspondence writes that “this study shows evidence of bias”, that “death rates do not indicate whether a war is lawful”, and that the authors multiplied recorded deaths “by up to three-fold”. The authors reply: “Our estimate is approximately 1·7 times the Gaza Ministry of Health’s estimate of deaths (64 260 vs 37 877) for the same time period, not three times”, and “we did not conduct a war crime investigation or determine legal responsibility”.
Corroboration: the Gaza Mortality Survey (Spagat, Pedersen, Shikaki, Robbins, Bendavid, Hegre and Guha-Sapir, “Violent and Nonviolent Death Tolls for the Gaza War: New Primary Evidence”, medRxiv preprint posted 20 June 2025), a household survey by a different team of authors, writes that its central estimate of the Ministry of Health undercount “closely matches a separate estimate made using capture-recapture methods” — this study (preprint, printed p. 1). Its authors also write that two of this study’s three data sources, and a strong majority of the deaths, “are components of the GMoH database itself”, so that the study “can offer only limited and partially circular assessment of GMoH overall numbers and their demographic disaggregates” (preprint, printed pp. 2–3). The survey covers 7 October 2023 to 5 January 2025, this study 7 October 2023 to 30 June 2024. The survey is the subject of a published letter: DellaPergola and Zlochin, “Population representativeness and interviewer-level heterogeneity in the Gaza Mortality Survey”, The Lancet Global Health, published online 11 June 2026, write that its estimates “should not be regarded as reliable measures of conflict-related deaths”.
What the source does not claim
The 41% is measured against the Ministry of Health’s own reported total for the same period — 37,877 decedents as of 30 June 2024, of whom 28,185 were identified. That total already includes 9,692 decedents the Ministry had not identified.
p. 1, Introduction; table 1, update 5
The authors report three alternative estimators beside their headline figure: a log-linear model (65,689), a mixed logit model (61,277), and a Bayesian model averaging model (50,663, 95% CI 45,912–55,980). The last falls below the lower bound of the published interval; the authors write that the BMA model “estimated fewer deaths” than the other models.
p. 6, Results; appendix p. 6
The 95% confidence interval is a Wald interval. The authors write that bootstrapping or profile intervals “might have better coverage” and that these “were computationally prohibitive given the large dataset and number of imputations”. They also write that “some residual dependence among lists might not have been reflected in the estimates due to model misspecification and the theoretical limits of any candidate modelling approach”.
p. 4, Statistical analysis; p. 7, Discussion
Hospitals in Gaza City and North Gaza governorates stopped reporting on 2 November 2023; the period the study covers runs from 7 October 2023 to 30 June 2024. The authors state they “were unable to stratify estimates by geography”.
table 1, footnote; p. 8, Discussion
The three lists together captured 45.4% (95% CI 37.2–52.7) of the estimated total. The remainder is inferred: the model puts 34,995 deaths (95% CI 26,034–49,262) on no list at all.
p. 6, Results
The authors write: “Our findings underestimate the full impact of the military operation in Gaza, as they do not account for non-trauma-related deaths resulting from health service disruption, food insecurity, and inadequate water and sanitation.” The estimate covers deaths from traumatic injury only.
p. 7
930 people reported missing were excluded from the main analysis. The authors run a separate sensitivity analysis that includes them as assumed decedents: “the overall estimate would increase to 68 662 (95% CI 58 735–84 472; see appendix p 8)”. The headline figure does not include them.
p. 3, Methods; p. 6, Results; p. 8, Discussion
The method infers deaths absent from every list. It is not a count of identified individuals, and no name attaches to the number.
p. 2–3, method
The authors assumed that the Ministry of Health hospital and survey lists “captured only deaths due to traumatic injury”. The survey asked about “those martyred”, and “some non-trauma deaths might have been included, potentially resulting in an overestimation of deaths due to traumatic injury”.
p. 7–8, Discussion, the limits: from “Additionally, we assumed that MoH hospital and survey lists” (p. 7) to “potentially resulting in an overestimation of deaths due to traumatic injury” (p. 8)
The headline figure is an average of the eight candidate models, each weighted by its posterior probability, not the output of a single model. In Table 2 the estimate of deaths outside any list runs from 20,862 to 47,825 across the eight models, against 34,995 (95% CI 26,034–49,262) for the average.
p. 4, Statistical analysis; p. 6, Table 2
Who counted
Two of the three lists come from the Palestinian Ministry of Health, the health authority of one party to the conflict. The study estimates that this authority under-reported traumatic-injury deaths by 41% over the period, and writes that its results support “the view that the MoH figures are more likely to underestimate than overestimate mortality”.
Provenance and verification — where this document came from, and what we could not
check ourselves
- Page numbers are those of the PDF file, numbered 1 to 9. The journal issue prints the article on pages 469 to 477: page 1 of the file is p. 469 and page 7 is p. 475. The two PDFs break pages at slightly different places: at the foot of pages 4, 5, 6 and 7 of the PDF of 9 January 2025, one line stands at the head of the next page in the issue PDF.
- The peer-reviewed article, 9 pages including its references, was read end to end on 20 September 2026 from the PDF “Published online January 9, 2025”, held by the authors’ institutional repository at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine. The PDF of the journal issue (Lancet 2025; 405: 469–77) was downloaded by hand from the publisher’s page, in an ordinary browser, on 4 October 2026 and compared with it word for word: the text is identical, and the quotations of this entry were checked against that file. thelancet.com forbids this registry by name in its robots file, so no request is sent there.
- Two of the three lists come from the Palestinian Ministry of Health, the health authority of one party to the conflict. Its data is admissible and is marked as such. Israeli official sources are marked the same way.
thelancet.com forbids this registry by name in its robots file, so no request was made there and the correction was not opened by our tool. It was read by hand on 19 September 2026.
Words used here, and what each one means:
Confidence interval · Capture–recapture · Sensitivity analysis · Party to the conflict
Cite this — the source document first, this entry second
Citing the document is what carries weight. This entry is where
you found it.
Plain text
The Lancet. Traumatic injury mortality in the Gaza Strip from Oct 7, 2023, to June 30, 2024: a capture–recapture analysis. 2025-01-09. At p. 1, Summary, "Findings"; restated p. 2, "Added value of this study". https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(24)02678-3.
Consulted via Only Receipts, entry jamaluddine-2025-001, https://www.onlyreceipts.org/entries/jamaluddine-2025-001/ (entry last changed 2026-10-04).
BibTeX
@misc{onlyreceipts-jamaluddine-2025-001,
author = {The Lancet},
title = {Traumatic injury mortality in the Gaza Strip from Oct 7, 2023, to June 30, 2024: a capture–recapture analysis},
year = {2025},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(24)02678-3},
urldate = {2026-09-17},
note = {p. 1, Summary, "Findings"; restated p. 2, "Added value of this study". Consulted via Only Receipts, https://www.onlyreceipts.org/entries/jamaluddine-2025-001/},
} RIS — Zotero, EndNote, Mendeley
TY - RPRT
AU - The Lancet
TI - Traumatic injury mortality in the Gaza Strip from Oct 7, 2023, to June 30, 2024: a capture–recapture analysis
PY - 2025
DA - 2025/01/09
UR - https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(24)02678-3
N1 - Locator: p. 1, Summary, "Findings"; restated p. 2, "Added value of this study"
N1 - Consulted via Only Receipts, entry jamaluddine-2025-001, https://www.onlyreceipts.org/entries/jamaluddine-2025-001/
ER -